White Teacher Sues California Union, Claiming They Blocked His Leadership Role Due to Race

By: Georgia | Published: May 31, 2024

A White history teacher, Isaac Newman, has taken a bold step by suing his local National Education Association affiliate in California. 

Newman claims the union prevented him from securing a leadership position solely based on his race. “My union barred me from a leadership position simply because of the color of my skin,” Newman stated, highlighting a stark violation of his civil rights under Title VII.

Exclusive Positions Spark Controversy

The heart of the dispute lies in the union’s decision to create a leadership seat exclusively for members of color. 

A man in a light beige suit and glasses standing and gesturing with his right hand while holding papers

Source: fauxels/Pexels

This move left Newman ineligible and feeling discriminated against. “It’s disgusting, and that’s why I’m suing,” he told Fox News Digital, expressing his outrage over what he views as a racially biased policy.


Legal Battle Over Racial Criteria

Newman’s lawsuit aims to challenge and overturn the union’s decision to establish a “BIPOC At-Large” seat. 

A close-up image of a black judge's gavel with a golden band on a dark surface

Source: Sora Shimazaki/Pexels

This position was specifically limited to candidates who self-identify as members of certain racial and ethnic groups, excluding white members like Newman. The lawsuit argues that this kind of racial differentiation is not only unfair but illegal.

A Stand Against DEI Policies

Aside from fighting for his own rights, Newman is vocal about his opposition to what he sees as aggressive Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) policies within the district. 

Overhead view of four diverse hands touching, symbolizing unity and teamwork, on a wooden table background

Source: Clay Banks/Unsplash

He believes these policies promote division rather than unity, focusing too much on race rather than individual merit and qualifications.

Fears for the Future

The implications of these policies are personal for Newman, extending beyond professional grievances. 

A lively elementary classroom scene with students raising their hands eagerly, sitting on the floor, participating in a group learning activity

Source: CDC/Unsplash

“I’m actually really frightened for my children,” he admitted, concerned about the long-term cultural shifts towards critical race theory and its impact on society.

Seeking Change in Educational Culture

By running for a union executive seat, Newman hopes to steer the district and union away from DEI ideologies.

A classroom scene with young students seated at desks, focused on tablets and books, while a teacher assists them

Source: Arthur Krijgsman/Pexels

He aims to advocate for a system that values merit and individuality, hoping to inspire other educators to voice their concerns and challenge the status quo.


Silent Majority in Education

Newman points out that many teachers share his views but remain silent, often fearing backlash. 

A woman in a red blouse is writing on a full chalkboard covered in various notes and diagrams

Source: Andrea Piacquadio/Pexels

He highlights a growing discomfort among educators with how race and meritocracy are treated in current educational debates.


Legal Perspectives on Union Policies

According to the Fairness Center, the legal group representing Newman, teachers’ unions are not exempt from laws prohibiting racial discrimination. 

A bald male teacher in a grey blazer and jeans discussing with a diverse group of young students seated at desks in a classroom

Source: Max Fischer/Pexels

“The Civil Rights Act explicitly forbids unions from discriminating based on race,” stated Nathan McGrath, President and General Counsel of the Fairness Center.


Community Reactions and Support

Newman’s case has stirred various reactions within the community.

A classroom with diverse students raising their hands to answer a question posed by their male teacher

Source: Max Fischer/Pexels

Some support his call for a non-discriminatory approach to leadership selection and others warn against undermining DEI initiatives that aim to address historical inequities.


Union’s Defense and Response

The union, on the other hand, defends its decision.

Close-up of a blue fabric chairback bag printed with the National Education Association logo and a "Red for Ed" support badge

Source: NEA Today/Facebook

They claim it is a step towards rectifying systemic imbalances and ensuring representation for historically marginalized groups within its leadership structure.


A Teacher's Hope for Justice

As the legal battle unfolds, Newman remains hopeful that the court will see the merit in his arguments and act to ensure that union positions are open to all, regardless of race. 

A male teacher standing in front of a classroom with middle school students

Source: Taylor Flowe/Unsplash

He views this case as a pivotal moment for ensuring fairness in how educational institutions handle diversity and leadership.


Implications for National Policies

The outcome of this lawsuit could have broader implications, potentially influencing how unions across the nation implement similar positions. 

A young boy in glasses and other elementary students intently working on art and math assignments in a busy classroom setting

Source: CDC/Unsplash

It’s a significant case that tests the boundaries of racial policies in educational leadership and union practices.