Walmart Pride
In a recent post on Instagram, Walmart promoted the introduction of its Pride collection with a video that received critical comments from several users.
Alexander Grey/Unsplash
“Did you learn nothing from target??,” one user wrote. “Sell your merchandise not lifestyles,” said another.
Pride Always
The 2024 Pride collection from Walmart is called “Pride Always.” The promotion for the collection advertises several products. There is a notebook with the words “beyond gender” written on it and a tote bag that says “totes gay.”
Source: Wikimedia Commons
“While I was creating my collection, it was important to me for it to be positive and uplifting,” said Bianca of Bianca Designs in the Walmart promo.
Walmart Statement
Walmart Chief Merchandising Officer Latriece Watkins expressed the company’s intent to not change its product offerings in response to a question last year about the previous Target controversy around Pride products.
Source: MikeMozartJeepersMedia/Wikimedia
“I think we have merchandise that we sell all year that supports different groups,” said Watkins. “I’d say in this particular case, we haven’t changed anything in our assortment.”
Target Controversy
The current climate of controversy around merchandise for Pride month heated up last year after viral videos were posted on products that some online found questionable at Target stores.
Source: Shabaz Usmani/Unsplash
Social media users started a campaign to boycott Target after “tuck-friendly” swimsuits were alleged to have been made for kids. However AP reported that the collection was for adults, not kids.
Boycott of Target
The frenzy drummed up on social media against Target reportedly hurt sales of Pride merchandise, causing the company this year to scale back on its collection by only allowing it in select stores.
Source: Brainulator9/Wikimedia Commons
This month Bloomberg reported that only half of Target’s around 2,000 stores will carry Pride merchandise, and Target said it will only sell “adult apparel” and home goods with a Pride theme.
Target Statement
The criticism that Target faced last year prompted the retailer to remove some of its Pride merchandise from store shelves. The company cited threats against employees as one of the motivating factors.
Source: Wikimedia Commons
“Given these volatile circumstances, we are making adjustments to our plans, including removing items that have been at the center of the most significant confrontational behavior,” Target said in a statement.
Disappointment in Target
Some have expressed disappointment with Target holding back on its Pride collection, feeling that the move is not fair to LGBT customers.
Alexander Grey/Unsplash
Human Rights Campaign President Kelley Robinson told NPR that the decision “alienates LGBTQ+ individuals and allies at the risk of not only their bottom line but also their values.”
Culture War
Companies like Target and Walmart are seemingly caught in a no-win scenario on this issue. If they limit their pride collections to avoid online backlash, they may also be seen as being unsupportive of LGBT members, which runs against their ideals.
Source: Kelly Sikkema/Unsplash
“Unfortunately for Target, it has been dragged into the culture wars and is in a position where it can’t win whatever it does,” said Neil Saunders, managing director of retail for GlobalData to CNN.
Conservative Backlash
Recently, conservatives and LGBT-critical voices have been influential with high-profile social media campaigns that are making companies think twice about embracing “woke” marketing strategies and products.
Source: Peter Muscutt/Unsplash
A backlash campaign against Bud Light who embraced a transgender influencer ended up costing Anheuser-Bush an estimated $1 billion in lost sales.
Go Woke, Go Broke
The mantra of “Go Woke Go Broke” has become a common saying among critics of certain companies that critics say are pushing progressive political agendas in a cynical manner.
Source: Towfiqu barbhuiya/Unsplash
This has landed companies right in the middle of a political struggle in an increasingly polarized America, one where every move they make risks alienating one group of its customers or another.
Social Media Backlash
While Walmart’s defiance in not scaling back its Pride collection is being celebrated by advocates online, many are taking to social media to express dissatisfaction with the collection.
Source: Alexander Grey/Unsplash
“Walmart launches new ‘Pride Always Collection’ to push LGBTQI+ ideology. As part of the collaboration, the retailer has launched products including a ‘Beyond Gender’ notebook. One of the LGBT designers says “I’m very excited to use it with my kids,” said gender-critical speaker Oli London on X.