‘This Was a Terrible Idea’: How One Event Broke Republicans’ Support for DeSantis

By: Georgia | Published: Sep 01, 2024

The controversial “Great Outdoors Initiative” aimed to transform Florida’s state parks by introducing development projects like 350-room hotels, golf courses, and pickleball courts. 

This plan, however, was met with substantial backlash from Republican senators Marco Rubio and Rick Scott, who criticized it as “absolutely ridiculous” in a joint letter.

Republican Leaders React

Republican congressman Brian Mast responded fiercely to the proposal, asserting it would happen “over my dead body.” 

Advertisement
Portrait of a smiling bald man in a formal suit against a plain blue background

Source: Wikimedia Commons

This strong opposition marked a significant shift as Mast, along with other Republican leaders, began to publicly challenge Governor Ron DeSantis’s previously unopposed policy directions.

Advertisement

No-Bid Contracts and Secrecy in Planning

The development plans for the initiative were revealed to have been drawn up secretly, involving no-bid contracts which were set to favor pre-selected developers, bypassing Florida’s legal requirements for public procurement. 

Advertisement
Entrance sign of Kissimmee Prairie Preserve State Park with a grassy field and palm trees in the background

Source: Wikimedia Commons

This lack of transparency in the planning process contributed to the growing discontent among Republican allies and the public alike.

Environmental Concerns Drive Opposition

Environmental advocates were particularly vocal, as the planned developments threatened habitats of species like the Florida scrub jays and gopher tortoises. 

Advertisement
A Florida Scrub Jay perched on a bare branch in its natural habitat, displaying its blue and gray plumage

Source: Wikimedia Commons

Their response highlighted a broader concern about the irreversible impact on Florida’s unspoiled acres at nine state parks, leading to widespread protests and activism.

Political Repercussions for DeSantis

Observers noted that this initiative could be a major political misstep for Governor DeSantis. 

Advertisement
Ron DeSantis speaking and gesturing with his hands while seated at a committee table in a hearing room

Source: Wikimedia Commons

His administration’s push to advance these development plans without broad consultation seemed to alienate even his staunchest supporters, indicating a potential shift in his political fortunes.

DeSantis Administration Retreats

Following the intense backlash, the DeSantis administration was forced to reconsider its approach. 

Governor Ron DeSantis giving a speech, dressed in a blue suit and red tie, with a blurred red background.

Source: Wikimedia Commons

The governor admitted the plans were “half-baked” and not yet “ready for prime time,” signaling a rare retreat in response to the wave of criticism.

Advertisement

DeSantis Denies Prior Knowledge of the Initiative

Governor DeSantis later claimed that the initiative was “leaked” and that he had not approved it, suggesting an attempt to distance himself from the fallout. 

Governor Ron DeSantis holding a microphone and speaking at an event, with an American flag in the background and audience members visible in the foreground

Source: Wikimedia Commons

He stated, “This is something that was leaked. It was not approved by me, I never saw that. It was intentionally leaked to a leftwing group to try and create a narrative.”

Advertisement

Media Questions DeSantis’s Political Grip

Following the controversy, media outlets began to speculate about the stability of DeSantis’s influence over Florida politics. 

Governor Ron DeSantis standing solemnly at a podium marked "DeSantis" with a blue and red campaign backdrop

Source: Wikimedia Commons

This incident exposed vulnerabilities in his leadership, previously unseen, prompting discussions about his ability to maintain control within the Republican Party.

Advertisement

Expert Analysis on Political Implications

Aubrey Jewett, a political science professor at the University of Central Florida, commented on the broader political implications, saying, “This was a totally self-inflicted political wound, a political error by Governor DeSantis and his administration.” 

Governor Ron DeSantis speaking at a podium with a vivid orange and red digital background, showcasing an ecological theme

Source: Wikimedia Commons

Jewett highlighted the misjudgment in pursuing a widely unpopular policy.

Advertisement

Changing Tides in Republican Support

The fallout from the initiative revealed deep fractures within the Republican Party’s support for DeSantis. 

Governor Ron DeSantis speaking at a podium with a large American flag backdrop, smiling towards an audience

Source: Wikimedia Commons

Many long-time allies began to publicly oppose his leadership, suggesting a shift in the political dynamics within the state.

Advertisement

DeSantis Addresses the Criticism

In response to mounting criticism, Governor DeSantis addressed the media, explaining his role and intentions. 

Governor Ron DeSantis gesturing while speaking at a podium in a conference room, wearing a blue suit and red tie

Source: GovRonDeSantis/X

He clarified, “I’ve never categorized [it] as me having a grip on anything,” emphasizing that his leadership was about setting agendas rather than micromanaging every detail.

Advertisement

Looking Ahead in Florida Politics

The controversy raised questions about the future of DeSantis’s political career and the broader trajectory of the Republican Party in Florida. 

Governor Ron DeSantis speaking at a press briefing, standing in front of a backdrop featuring the U.S. and Florida state flags

Source: GovRonDeSantis/X

With the governor nearing the end of his term and facing decreased influence, the state’s political landscape appears poised for significant changes. This incident serves as a pivotal moment, potentially reshaping Florida’s political alignment and leadership dynamics.

Advertisement