Struggling Starbucks Moves To Replace Their CEO With Chipotle’s CEO, Resulting in Best Stock Day on Record

By: Alex Trent | Published: Aug 14, 2024

Following recently disappointing quarterly earnings reports, American coffee giant Starbucks has committed to a new change in leadership.

Starbucks has now ousted former CEO Laxman Narasimhan effective immediately and announced his replacement as Chipotle CEO Brian Niccol who will take over on September 9.

Starbucks Announcment

On Tuesday, Starbucks announced the sudden switch up in senior leadership in a press release published on their website, naming Rachel Ruggeri as interim CEO.

Advertisement
Two Starbucks coffee cups on a wooden table in a cozy café setting, with a newspaper in the background

Source: Marco Chilese/Unsplash

“[Starbucks] today announced that Brian Niccol has been appointed chairman and chief executive officer. Niccol will start in his new role on September 9, 2024,” the statement said. “Laxman Narasimhan is stepping down as CEO and as a director effective immediately. Rachel Ruggeri will serve as interim CEO.”

Advertisement

Excitement for Niccol

In their statement, Starbucks extolled the virtues of Niccol, who they saw as an innovator and value creator.

Advertisement
Exterior of a Chipotle restaurant, showing the sign prominently

Source: Alamy

“Niccol has transformed Chipotle,” the statement said. “His focus on people and culture, brand, menu innovation, operational excellence, and digital transformation have set new standards in the industry and driven significant growth and value creation.”

Revenue Generator

Starbucks also highlighted his financial accomplishments in his role at the restaurant brand which did not come at the cost of sacrificing worker benefits.

Advertisement
A briefcase filled with $100 bills.

Source: Pixabay/Pexels

“Revenue has nearly doubled, profits have increased nearly sevenfold, and the stock price has increased by nearly 800% during his leadership, all while increasing wages for retail team members, expanding benefits, and strengthening the culture,” said the Starbucks statement.

Phenomenal Career

Mellody Hobson, who was named lead independent director, gushed praise and was thankful for the opportunity to work with Niccol.

Advertisement
A Chipotle meal served with chips and a drink.

Missvain/Wikimedia

“We are thrilled to welcome Brian to Starbucks. His phenomenal career speaks for itself. Brian is a culture carrier who brings a wealth of experience and a proven track record of driving innovation and growth,” Hobson said.

Experienced Business Leader

According to the statement, Niccol currently serves on the board of directors for Walmart and previously he was on the boards for KB Home and Harley-Davidson.

The exterior of a Taco Bell restaurant.

Source: Michael Rivera/wikimedia

Before becoming the Chipotle CEO in 2018, he served as Chief Executive Officer for the Mexican-inspired food chain Taco Bell from 2015 to 2018. 

Advertisement

Niccol’s Statement

Niccol was quoted in the Starbucks statement as excited to join, mentioning a long-held admiration for the brand.

A close-up of a white and green Starbucks coffee cup.

Source: Engin Akyurt/Pexels

“I am excited to join Starbucks and grateful for the opportunity to help steward this incredible company, alongside hundreds of thousands of devoted partners,” said Niccol. “I have long-admired Starbucks iconic brand, unique culture and commitment to enhancing human connections around the globe.

Advertisement

Thanking Laxman

While Starbucks is moving on from its current CEO, Hobson took a moment to thank Narasimhan for his efforts and blamed “challenging headwinds” for the company’s latest struggles.

A close-up portrait of Starbucks CEO, speaking in a meeting, slightly out of focus

Source: Wikimedia Commons

“On behalf of the board, I want to sincerely thank Laxman for his contributions to Starbucks, and his dedication to our people and brand,” said Hobson. “In the face of some challenging headwinds, Laxman has been laser focused on improving the business to meet the needs of our customers and partners. We all wish him the very best and know he will do great things in the future.”    

Advertisement

Best Stock Day Ever

CNBC reports that the decision to axe Laxman Narasimhan sent Starbucks stock soaring to its best day ever, gaining 24.5%.

A close-up of a Starbucks store in California.

Source: Mahavir Shah/Unsplash

By contrast, the news negatively affected Chipotle’s stock, which fell by 10% as news that their CEO would be leaving broke.

Advertisement

Starbucks' Struggles

The coffee giant has been struggling with sales in recent months, with their latest earnings report showing a 3% decline in same-store sales globally, the second straight quarter of global decline.

Starbucks employees working behind the counter.

Source: Vaishnav Chogale/Unsplash

This Starbucks sales slump has been driven by declines in the United States and China, which are its two largest markets.

Advertisement

Pricing Backlash

As some customers struggle with tough economic conditions, many are choosing to cut back on eating out and preferring to brew their coffee cheaper at home.

A white mug on a saucer filled with coffee.

Source: Emre/Unsplash

In April, analysts from Deutsche Bank found that 45% of Starbucks customers are buying less or no longer buying from Starbucks at all, with the top reason reported being “it’s become too expensive.”

Advertisement

Schultz Open Letter

In May, former Starbucks CEO Howard Schultz, who had handpicked Narasimhan to succeed him, pinned an open letter criticizing the company’s direction and offered advice going forward.

Front view of a Starbucks Coffee shop featuring large glass windows and doors, with the iconic green and white Starbucks logo on a circular sign to the left

Source: Mr.ちゅらさん/Wikimedia Commons

“At any company that misses badly, there must be contrition and renewed focus and discipline on the core. Own the shortcoming without the slightest semblance of an excuse,” said Schultz in the letter.

Advertisement