“She Should Have Some of Her Own”: J.D. Vance Slams “Childless” Teachers Union President

By: David Donovan | Published: Aug 28, 2024

In remarks from 2021 that resurfaced on Tuesday, Republican vice presidential nominee Sen. JD Vance of Ohio criticized teachers who do not have children following previous comments over “childless cat ladies”.

In his public remarks, Vance took particular aim at Randi Weingarten, the head of the American Federation of Teachers.

“Brainwash the Minds of Our Children”

Vance made the comments at a Center for Christian Virtue leadership forum in October 2021, which was moderated by conservative radio host Hugh Hewitt and the group’s president, Aaron Baer.

Advertisement
Vance speaking at the 2024 People's Convention, he holds a mic in his hand and is mid speech as he gesticulates with his other hand

Source: Gage Skidmore/Flickr

“You know, so many of the leaders of the left, and I hate to be so personal about this, but they’re people without kids, trying to brainwash the minds of our children”

Advertisement

Senate Race

In Ohio’s 2022 Senate race, other Republican candidates ran alongside Vance.

Advertisement
JD Vance at 2018 TechCrunch Disrupt Conference, San Francisco, he has a mic attached to his head and is gesticulating with his arms as he talks.

Source: TechCrunch/Flickr

At the point when the candidates were questioned about taking care of issues with schools and making them more receptive to parents, Vance focused on Weingarten, who has depicted herself as “a mother by marriage,” by saying she “doesn’t have a single child.”

“Leave Ours the Hell Alone”

In a 30-second clip that was republished on the liberal news website Heartland Signal on Tuesday, he stated, “If she wants to brainwash and destroy the mind of children, she should have some of her own and leave ours the hell alone.” 

Advertisement
JD Vance walking alongside a group of people in suit with an airplane in the background on a runway as well as vehicles

Source: JDVance/X

VP Kamala Harris’ campaign later reposted the clip.

Previous remarks from 2021 in which he referred to Harris as one of the “childless cat ladies” who “want to make the rest of the country miserable, too” drew widespread criticism from Vance.

Advertisement
Kamala Harris in a gym with her hand around a young girl holding a basketball as other people look on and clap for them.

Source: VP/X

Weingarten, whose union gave Harris its support a month ago, spoke last week at the Democratic National Convention in support of her run for president.

“Defend our Kids”

Taylor Van Kirk, a representative for Vance, said in a statement to NBC News on Tuesday that Vance “will continue to loudly call this crap out to defend our kids.”

JD Vance with his wife entering onto a rally stage as people sit in stands in the background blurred.

Source: JDVance/X

Van Kirk stated, “There is no bigger threat to American children than the left wing indoctrination being peddled in our schools by radicals like Randi Weingarten, with the support of Kamala Harris and Tim Walz.”

Advertisement

“Insulting to Millions of Modern Families”

Weingarten provided remarks on the clip on X, which a spokesperson for the teacher’s union directed outlets toward when asked for comment.

Randi Weingarten posing with three other people wearing AFT shirts in support of Obama and Biden

Source: Laura Markwardt/Flickr

“Gross! JD Vance’s comments are sad and insulting to millions of modern families, and school teachers including Catholic nuns, none of whom should be targeted for their family decisions,” Weingarten stated.

Advertisement

“Unprecedented Power”

National Education Association President Becky Pringle said in a release to NBC News that former President Donald Trump and Vance need to have greater respect for teachers who “dedicate their lives to serving students.”

Becky Pringle posing for a photo with two other women at the Democratic National Convention 2024 as other people are in the background

Source: BeckyPringle/X

According to Pringle, “Instead they choose to attack and demean us while pushing an extreme, unprecedented Project 2025 agenda on America that will fundamentally jeopardize our children’s futures and give Trump unprecedented power over our daily lives.”

Advertisement

Cotton’s Remarks

Vance isn’t the only Republican to criticize Weingarten’s parental status.

U.S. secretary of defense Ash Carter and senators Joni Ernst, Daniel Sullivan, John McCain, Tom Cotton, Lindsey Graham, and Cory Gardner attending the 2016 International Institute for Strategic Studies Asia Security Summit in Singapore

Source: Ash Carter/Flickr

In a Fox News interview in 2021, Republican Sen. Tom Cotton for Arkansas stated, “Randi Weingarten is a joke. Randi Weingarten does not even have children of her own. What in the hell does she know about raising and teaching kids?”

Advertisement

Greene’s Statement

Republican Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene for Georgia, made similar comments about Weingarten the last year.

Greene with her congressional office staff, "Team Greene", on her first day in office, January 3, 2021, Greene has her thumbs up and sits at a desk while her team stand around her.

Source: RepMTG/X

Greene’s Democratic colleagues leveled criticism at the Representative when she told Weingarten that, “The problem is, people like you need to admit that you’re just a political activist, not a teacher, not a mother and not a medical doctor.”

Advertisement

AFT Support

In July the AFT became the first union to endorse Harris and passed their resolution unanimously by the union’s executive council.

Randi Weingarten speaking on stage at IUPAT, there are people at a table on stage and cameras recording her speech

Source: AFTunion/X

The AFT stated on its website that they had “long championed the Biden-Harris administration for its support of workers, families, unions and democracy, and supporting Harris is an enthusiastic renewal of that commitment.”

Advertisement

Differing Positions

In the AFT’s statement supporting Harris, they compared Harris and Trump’s track record on education.

Randi Weingarten speaking with another woman in a hotel function room at the DNC2024 as other people are behind them

Source: AFTunion/X

This included highlighting the investment in mental wellness, championing public schools, career and technical education, and community schools.

In contrast, they claimed that Trump and his secretary of education, Betsy Devos “sought to demonize, defund and destabilize” public education.

Advertisement