Part of a NYC Office Tower Just Sold for $1

By: Beth Moreton | Published: Mar 04, 2024

With commercial real estate now at an all-time high, the future is looking particularly bleak for companies renting office spaces.

A Canadian pension fund company recently sold its stake in a New York City office tower for just $1. What does that mean?

The COVID-19 Pandemic Started Real Estate Issues

When the COVID-19 pandemic began, this started a precedent for employees to be able to work from home.

Advertisement
Three nurses dressed in blue aprons and white masks standing next to boxes of hospital supplies.

Source: IAEA Imagebank/Wikimedia Commons

With this still ongoing and many workers able to work from pretty much anywhere, and inflation causing high interest rates, this began a fear of what is to become of real estate.

Advertisement

Investors Are Keen to Sell their Commercial Real Estate Investments

Where commercial real estate was once a good investment to make, the pandemic and inflation have made this a less viable investment, according to Business Insider.

Advertisement
Two sets of office buildings with some building work going on behind them.

Source: Someone not awful/Wikimedia Commons

As companies are less likely to be using office space and with those that do allow many workers to work from home, investors are starting to struggle with justifying these investments.

Canadian Pension Funds Were Very Prolific in Real Estate

According to Bloomsburg, Canadian Pension Funds were once prolific investors in real estate and encouraged other pension funds to follow suit.

Advertisement
Some office buildings in America. There are some trees surrounding the buildings.

Source: Av3553/Wikimedia Commons

Despite them previously leading the charge in making real estate investments, they are now causing investors to believe they should invest their money elsewhere.

A Canadian Pension Fund Sold Their Stake for $1

One of the major Canadian pension funds, the Canadian Pension Plan Investment Board (CPPIB), recently sold its stake in an NYC office tower for just $1.

Advertisement
A close-up shot of a person holding a one-dollar bill.

Source: Wirestock/Freepik

The CPPIB was in debt. Their plans for the building were to redevelop it. They have since sold it to Boston Properties, who bought the stake for $1 and have taken on CPPIB’s debt.

CPPIB Also Sold Some of Its Other Investments

Aside from the New York building that sold for $1, CPPIB also sold some other investments, which has increased the anxiety surrounding real estate investments.

The skyline in Vancouver. There are a lot of office buildings alongside a body of water. Opposite this is lots of trees. There are some boats on the water.

Source: David G. Gordon/Wikipedia

The other real estate investments sold were a pair of Vancouver towers and a business park in Southern California.

Advertisement

CPPIB Lost Money on Its Other Investments

While having a 29% stake bought for $1 seems like a massive loss, CPPIB also lost big amounts of money on its other investments.

A woman sat at her desk doing some calculations on her phone while working on her laptop. She has some small piles of money next to her.

Source: Tima Miroshnichenko/Pexels

For example, according to Business Insider, the Southern California business park that they had a 45% stake in sold for $38 million. This might be more than $1, but it is a loss of 75% compared to what they bought it for in 2018.

Advertisement

Banks Are Saying That Offices Are a Bad Investment

Banks from New York to Tokyo are warning investors that investing in offices in the current climate is a bad idea, according to Mint.

A laptop open to show some stock going up and down. The stock is going up and down slightly, only for the more recent figures to show it going down rapidly. The lines on the graph are red and green.

Source: m/Unsplash

New York Community Bancorp slashed its dividend and stockpile reserves, causing its stock to go down 38%, and Aozora Bank warned of losses tied to U.S. commercial property investments, causing their stock to go down 20%.

Advertisement

CPPIB Has a Large Investment Portfolio

CPPIB has a large investment fund of $590.8 billion, with $41.4 billion in real estate.

A laptop open on a desk showing an investment portfolio that has various figures and graphs on it.

Source: Carlos Muza/Unsplash

The types of real estate CPPIB has invested in include warehouses and apartment blocks. Due to the size of this portfolio, something such as selling a 29% state in a New York office for $1 is enough to cause worry across the investment world.

Advertisement

CPPIB Says There Is Nothing to Worry About

While many investors are worried about what CPPIB selling its stake in an office building for $1 will do to the real estate sector, CPPIB says there is nothing to worry about.

A tall tower office building with glass windows.

Source: Image2012/Wikimedia Commons

Petter Ballon, who is the global head of CPPIB’s real estate, has said that selling is an important part of investing and that they will sell their share when they have maximized its value, according to Financial Post.

Advertisement

Making a Return Investment Will Cost You a Lot of Money

With there being a lack of demand in office spaces, this has changed how investors are investing their money.

A zoomed-in shot of a person holding money in notes.

Source: Roman Synkevych/Unsplash

Matt Hershey, who is a partner at Hodes Weill & Associates, has said that investors will now have to put lots of money into an office to get better returns and advises that it might be best to cut any losses and invest money elsewhere.

Advertisement

Office Spaces May Be Turned into Residential Buildings

As many people are now working from home and there is less of a need for office space, an idea has been suggested that office space should be turned into residential buildings.

A skyline view of various tall buildings, including offices and residential buildings.

Source: Jeshua Sharkey/Unsplash

According to Business Insider, this could be tricky, as not all office space has been designed or constructed to be residential space; however, with a bit of planning and time, it is doable.

Advertisement

Office Vacancies Will Rise … But That’s Not the Solution

With office vacancies currently being at 13.5% and expected to rise to 18% in the next decade, some believe that this could help the housing shortage.

An empty office. There are desks with chairs and computers with no people inside the buildings.

Source: Adolfo Félix/Unsplash

But Business Insider says this isn’t possible, as Goldman Sachs has stated that only 4% of office space is viable for conversion. So with this and the loss investors are making in offices, it’s unclear as to when or if this issue will be solved.

Advertisement