Newsom Said He Wouldn’t Raise Taxes; His Budget Now Proposes $18 Billion in Business Tax Hikes

By: Georgia | Published: May 22, 2024

California Governor Gavin Newsom, addressing the state’s $73 billion deficit earlier this month, firmly stated to reporters, “the answer is no,” when questioned about raising taxes to solve the fiscal crisis. 

Despite these assurances, his recent budget proposal includes $18 billion in tax hikes specifically targeting businesses, revealing a significant shift in strategy.

Previous Commitments Versus Current Actions

Governor Newsom had previously pledged not to increase taxes, particularly in the context of a budget crisis that has emerged just two years after the state enjoyed a nearly $100 billion surplus. 

Governor Gavin Newsom speaking at a desk in a legislative setting, accompanied by other officials and a nun in the background.

Source: CAgovernor/X

Despite this, his current budget proposal laid out plans for considerable tax increases on businesses.


Newsom's Budget Proposal Details

On May 10, Governor Newsom unveiled a budget proposal which was detailed further the following week. 

Governor Gavin Newsom stands at a podium with a digital screen behind him displaying a budget revision presentation

Source: CAgovernor/X

The proposal seeks to restrict businesses with earnings of $1 million or more from deducting operating losses from their taxes and limit their business tax credits. These measures are intended to generate approximately $18 billion through 2027.

Focus on Protecting Small Businesses

The tax adjustments introduced in the budget are described by state finance department spokesman H.D. Palmer as “designed to protect small businesses.” 

A chalkboard sign placed outside a store, with the message "Thank You for shopping local" written in stylish cursive and block letters

Source: Tim Mossholder/Unsplash

He emphasized that the changes would affect only a small percentage of corporations, primarily impacting how they claim credits for research and development.

Timing of Tax Increases Criticized

The proposed tax hikes have been met with criticism. 

Night-time view of a busy restaurant kitchen seen through a large window, with neon "OPEN" sign glowing above

Source: Khachik Simonian/Unsplash

David Kline, vice president of communications and research for the California Taxpayers Association, highlighted the poor timing, saying, “this would be the worst possible time to impose $18 billion in additional business taxes that would trigger job losses and higher costs for consumers.”

Economic Uncertainty Caused by Tax Proposals

Jon Coupal, president of the California tax watchdog group Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association, criticized the proposed taxes for creating “a climate of economic uncertainty” and described it as “playing a risky game with people’s jobs.” 

Close-up of Governor Gavin Newsom smiling, wearing a blue suit and a white shirt, outdoor setting

Source: Wikimedia Commons

His comments reflect concerns over nearly half a million residents losing their jobs in the state earlier this year.


Concerns Over Business Stability

The tax changes could undermine business confidence, as Jon Coupal pointed out. 

Sunset view over San Francisco showing a blend of high-rise buildings and residential areas, with prominent skyscrapers like the Salesforce Tower and Transamerica Pyramid visible against a hazy sky

Source: Hardik Pandya/Unsplash

He stated, “The suspension of established tax credits and net operating loss deductions sends a message to businesses that California may yank the rug out from under them any time the budget is under stress, even when that stress is caused by reckless government overspending.”


Budget Growth Despite Population Decline

Governor Newsom’s proposed $288 billion budget is a significant increase from the budgets during his tenure beginning in 2019.

Governor Gavin Newsom speaking at a podium in a conference room, with digital screens displaying financial charts about revenue and capital gains, and an audience of professionals listening intently

Source: CAgovernor/X

It is also much higher than his predecessor’s $201 billion in 2018-19, even though California now has at least 300,000 fewer residents.


Economic Stagnation and Fiscal Measures

California’s economic stagnation and a decrease in tax revenues, exacerbated by an exodus of both high-earning residents and businesses, have driven the need for these tax increases. 

Urban street scene showing the storefronts of Buck Mason and Matchabar, with a parked car in front and a streetcar passing by, in a vibrant neighborhood setting

Source: Charles Etoroma/Unsplash

The state’s economic challenges are deepening, necessitating decisive fiscal measures.


The Ongoing Debate Over Tax Hikes

The implications of these proposed tax hikes are a subject of intense debate. 

Governor Gavin Newsom speaking enthusiastically at a podium with a 'California Democrats' banner in the background, under blue lighting

Source: Wikimedia Commons

Citizens are weighing whether these measures will stabilize California’s fiscal situation or further challenge the economic environment, particularly impacting businesses.


Diverse Impact on State’s Economy

The administration claims the tax proposals are aimed at protecting small businesses while ensuring that larger corporations contribute more during the economic downturn.

Rainy day on a busy San Francisco street with American flags hanging from buildings, pedestrians hurrying across the street, and vehicles including a bus in motion

Source: Josh Hild/Unsplash

This approach, however, has stirred a debate on its fairness and effectiveness in addressing the state’s financial issues.


The Future of California’s Economy

The outcome of these proposed tax changes will be crucial in determining the future economic direction of California. 

Governor Gavin Newsom laughing and interacting with a diverse group of people in a room with a blue banner featuring the California state emblem in the background

Source: CAgovernor/X

As the state contends with these fiscal proposals, the responses from businesses and residents will shape the political and economic landscape in the coming years.