New Study Reveals 72% of Americans Feel Democracy Is Dead

By: Beth Moreton | Published: Aug 19, 2024

Politics has taken a different turn in recent years. While people used to feel that they could trust democracy to do the right thing, these feelings have dramatically changed, and most Americans now feel democracy is dead.

There are a few reasons, with Republicans and Democrats completely switching their opinions in the last few years. People from other countries also agree that American democracy is no longer an excellent example of what democracy should look like. 

The U.S. Used to Be a Good Example of Democracy

The most commonly held opinion in this survey was that the U.S. used to be a good example of democracy, which is an opinion that 72% of Americans hold. These people believe that democracy in the U.S. hasn’t been as good as it used to be in the last few years.

Advertisement
The U.S. flag on a flagpole.

Source: Zetong Li/Unsplash

In comparison, just 8% of those surveyed believe that the U.S. has never been a good example of democracy, with 19% believing that it is still a good example. 

Advertisement

Democrats vs Republicans

The party people most closely affiliate themselves with tends to sway voters’ opinion on whether the U.S. is a good example of democracy. However, Democrat’s and Republican’s views have changed in the last few years.

Advertisement
The Republican and Democratic logos. On the left is the Republican logo, a red elephant, and on the right is the Democratic logo, a blue donkey.

Source: Sagearbor/Wikimedia Commons

22% of Democrats and 17% of Republicans believe the U.S. is a good example of democracy. Despite this, in February 2021, the opposite was true, as 16% of Democrats and 24% of Republicans believed that U.S. democracy was good. 

Age Matters in Democracy

According to a different survey, age matters regarding opinions on democracy. In this survey, 73% of voters said that democracy is the best system, with only 13% disagreeing with this statement.

Advertisement
An old and a young person looking at each other and smiling.

Source: Nathan Anderson/Unsplash

However, the main difference was in age. Of the voters aged 18 to 35, only 53% are pro-democracy, and 25% are skeptical about it. Compared to voters aged 65 and older, 89% are pro-democracy, with just 6% being skeptical.

Registered vs. Unregistered Voters

There also appears to be a difference in opinion between registered and unregistered voters. 21% of registered voters see U.S. democracy as a good example, compared to 13% of unregistered voters.

Advertisement
Two signs outside a building direct voters to where they need to vote. One sign says, “Vote here,” and the other says, “Vote here, district #7.”

Source: Ernie Journeys/Unsplash

There is no exact reason why this might be, but it is an interesting look into people’s thoughts and opinions depending on their voter status.

Canadians Don’t Believe in American Democracy

Just over the northern part of the U.S. border, Canadians now say that they don’t believe in American democracy. Two-thirds believe the U.S. won’t survive if Donald Trump gets another four years in office.

The Canadian flag on a flagpole in the sky.

Source: Hermes Rivera/Unsplash

This poll was taken before Joe Biden had to drop out of the presidential race. Still, at that time, 53% of Canadians believed that it would be more beneficial for Canada if Biden had a second term as President, whereas 18% thought it would be better if Trump became President.

Advertisement

Other Countries View U.S. Democracy Poorly

It’s not just Canada that views U.S. democracy negatively; plenty of other countries also have the same opinion. 34 countries were surveyed, and the majority responded that U.S. democracy isn’t a good example.

Voter stickers of the U.S. flag that have “I voted” on them.

Source: visuals/Unsplash

France and Mexico were the most critical, as 40% of people from both countries believe that the U.S. isn’t a good example of democracy. Meanwhile, 60% of respondents from Germany, the UK, and Japan believe that while the U.S. used to be a good example of democracy, this is no longer the case.

Advertisement

Political Events Have Tainted People’s Views

One of the main reasons people are losing their faith in U.S. democracy is due to various political events and incidents over the last few years. The most recent was the assassination attempt on Donald Trump.

An image of Donald Trump with blood on his face. The Secret Service surrounds him, and there is a crowd of people behind the state.

Source: @LeadingReport/X

There was also the issue of Trump being the first convicted felon to run for U.S. President and Biden’s struggles when answering questions and taking part in debates, which eventually led to him pulling out of his re-run for President.

Advertisement

Bernie Sanders Democracy Warning

It’s not just ordinary citizens concerned about the state of U.S. democracy. Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders has issued a stark warning about the potential state of democracy in the states.

A crowd of people holding U.S. flags.

Sources: Dyana Wing So/Unsplash

Sanders warned that the U.S. would likely become an oligarchy due to three major institutional investors holding all the power. BlackRock, Vanguard and State Street have trillions of dollars of wealth and are significant shareholders in 500 U.S. companies. 

Advertisement

A Reduced Ballot Vote

One issue many people are having is that since 2010, there have been continuing efforts from state legislatures to try and limit voters’ access to the ballot, which has a significant impact on the types of people who vote and the people who end up being voted in.

A reel of stickers with the U.S. flag that says “I voted.”

Source: Element5 Digital/Unsplash

There have also been efforts to politicize election administration and to foreclose electoral competition through extreme gerrymandering. This has people worried about the state the U.S. will be in over the next few years and beyond.

Advertisement

Democracy Decline Is Slow

Many people believe that if politicians wanted to eliminate democracy, it would happen quickly, and no one would have a say in how or why it happened. However, this isn’t how it works.

An upward view of the U.S. flag on a silver flagpole outside a building.

Source: Jonathan Simcoe/Unsplash

Democracy’s decline is slow on purpose. This is in the hope that voters don’t realize a decline in democracy until it is too late and not much more can be done about it. 

Advertisement

Democrat's Warnings on Democracy

The Democrats are currently in power in the U.S., but there is a worry that Donald Trump could beat them in the 2024 U.S. presidential election. This has led Democrats to issue a stark warning to Americans regarding democracy.

A view of the U.S. Capitol building with birds flying near it.

Source: Mayer Tawfik/Unsplash

Instead of saying it is a vote on taxes or healthcare, they have pitched the election as being a vote between continuing as a republic or having a dictatorship, with voters’ decisions making all the difference.

Advertisement