More Men Than Ever Are Choosing Not to Work

By: Georgia | Published: May 07, 2024

Recent figures from the Bureau of Labor Statistics highlight a concerning shift: just 89% of working-age men are now employed or seeking employment, a notable drop from the 97% participation rate in 1950. 

This dramatic change illustrates a profound transformation in male workforce engagement over the past seventy years.

A Look Back at the 1950s

Taking a trip back to the 1950s, the employment scene in America tells a different story. 

A black and white photo of a 1960s electronics lab with men working at various stations filled with large electronic measurement devices and computers

Source: Wikimedia Commons

During that era, approximately 96% of people between the ages of 25 and 54 were in the workforce, either in full-time or part-time roles. Today, that percentage has sharply declined to 86%.


Understanding the Broader Consequences

The drop in male employment has caught the attention of experts who are worried about its long-term effects on both the economy and society. 

A group of young adults engaged in work at a long table in a well-lit, modern coworking space with laptops, wearing casual clothing and headphones

Source: Annie Spratt/Unsplash

Robin Brooks from the Brookings Institution stresses the severity, saying, “The U.S. has a major issue of prime-age men giving up and permanently exiting the labor force.”

An Overlooked Issue

Despite its potential repercussions, this trend isn’t getting the spotlight it deserves. 

Aerial view of a large construction site with numerous workers in safety gear inspecting and installing rebar on a large concrete foundation

Source: Scott Blake/Unsplash

Brooks criticizes the lack of coverage, noting, “What’s striking about this is that it doesn’t get talked about at all, not in the mainstream media and not by economists, even though this obviously feeds political radicalization.”

Recession and Its Lasting Impact

Historically, economic downturns have triggered declines in workforce participation from which full recovery is rare.

A vivid red sign with graffiti stating "IT'S NOT A RECESSION IT'S A REGRESSION", with additional street art and stickers surrounding the text

Source: Annie Spratt/Unsplash

After the 2008 Recession, for instance, male employment fell from 88% to 80.6% and hasn’t climbed back over 86.7% since then.

Pandemic Effects Echo Historical Patterns

The COVID-19 pandemic caused a similar downturn, with male workforce participation dropping to 78% in 2020. 

A close-up of a notice on a store door stating "Due to COVID-19, our store is closed to the public. HOWEVER Phone orders with curbside pickups available" with contact information below

Source: Erik Mclean/Unsplash

Although there has been some rebound, numbers remain significantly lower than those of the 1950s.


A Growing Educational Divide

There’s also a widening gap in educational attainment. Currently, women outnumber men in college completion rates, 60 to 40%.

View from behind a female graduate wearing a cap and gown at a commencement ceremony, with a focus on her square academic cap and the purple tassel hanging to the side

Source: MD Duran/Unsplash

This shift is reshaping job prospects and job security for many men, influencing their roles in the labor market.


Education and Employment Correlation

Employment prospects differ drastically by educational level.

A diverse group of high school graduates in caps and gowns excitedly waving their diplomas during a graduation ceremony

Source: Caleb Woods/Unsplash

The Bureau of Labor Statistics points out that individuals with just a high school diploma face a 3.9% unemployment rate, much higher than the 2.2% for those with a bachelor’s degree.


Earnings, Education, and Esteem

Financial disparities tied to education are growing.

Two male professionals working in a modern office setting with large monitors and laptops, visibly engaged in their software development tasks

Source: Tim van der Kuip/Unsplash

A Federal Reserve Bank of Boston study suggests that deteriorating social status linked to job market conditions is a significant factor affecting self-esteem, noting, “This finding suggests that deteriorating social status is a plausible key factor.”


Changes in Social Support Systems

Social Security disability benefits have seen a drastic increase from 455,000 recipients in 1960 to 7.6 million in 2022.

A close-up shot of an assortment of U.S. currency, featuring various denominations of bills including ones, fives, tens, and twenties, spread out on a surface

Source: Alexander Schimmeck/Unsplash

This group includes 1.3 million men aged 25 to 54, highlighting a significant shift in America’s social safety nets.


Industry Shifts Redefining Work

As Yvonne Vissing of Salem State University points out, job market shifts have a profound effect on whether people can work.

A cropped view of a businessman in a blue suit carrying a brown leather briefcase, walking on a city street with a focus on his lower half

Source: Marten Bjork/Unsplash

She explains, “If the jobs don’t meet people’s needs, people can’t work. It’s not that they won’t work. They can’t, given the job options, locations, tasks, hours, pay, and environments that are available.”


The Quest for Meaningful Work

More men are searching for work that is not only financially but also emotionally rewarding. 

A young man with a beard, wearing glasses and a casual mustard-colored jacket, working on a laptop in a cafe surrounded by lush green plants, giving a thumbs up while holding a smartphone in his other hand

Source: DocuSign/Unsplash

Vissing captures this sentiment, stating, “Many jobs are simply not satisfying. Working for others who get the benefit of our physical labor and intellectual property is not rewarding either emotionally or financially. People want to work doing jobs that matter to us.”