Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer’s Controversial New Budget Plan Sparks Outrage

By: David Donovan | Published: Aug 26, 2024

Gretchen Whitmer, Governor of Michigan, has just approved a billion state spending plan for the Financial Year 2025. It’s a $82.5 billion spending plan with an emphasis on public safety financial stability and improvements to public infrastructure.

Whitmer appeared to be proud of the budget when it was announced. 

“Balanced, Fiscally Responsible Budget”

According to Whitmer, “What we have done here is create another balanced, fiscally responsible budget that doesn’t raise taxes by a dime, but yet makes another deposit into our rainy day fund which claims a new all time high of $2.2 billion.”

Advertisement
Gretchen Whitmer arriving at the Capitol dais for her inauguration ceremony as new governor, January 2019, she is walking down stairs with American flags on them accompanied by an official.

Source: 1st Lt. Andrew Layton, U.S. Air National Guard/Michigan National Guard

Mike Duggan, Mayor of Detroit, was additionally excited about the state’s money infusion. Detroit is getting some serious assistance – with $100 million for affordable housing and more than $500 million for supplanting lead water lines.

Advertisement

Investing in Public Safety

Duggan stated, “In previous times, Lansing waited until there was a crisis on the lead pipes to act. But we are right now replacing 200 houses a week with new pipes.”

Advertisement
Mike Duggan at a March 2022 event with Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer, they are in a garage with a truck behind them that has been raised as Whitmer holds a piece of paper and the two smile.

Source: City of Detroit/Flickr

This budget prioritizes public safety by establishing the Public Safety Trust Fund, which will receive $75 million to support community violence intervention and law enforcement.

Community Heroes

Local area violence groups have previously been out in large numbers in Detroit’s Warrendale, and their effect has been noticeable. Duggan claims that these community heroes reduced the number of shootings by 70%.

Advertisement
Mike Duggan taking his oath of office for his second term as mayor, he has his hand raised as a woman stands opposite him with her hand raised mid speech.

Source: City of Detroit/Flickr

Duggan said, “The folks who are in the neighborhoods who are preventing the shots in the first place, they were funded with federal money that was going to expire in July.”

“This Budget Gets it Done”

Other cities in Michigan are expected to follow suit, including Detroit, which is adding 100 new police officers.

Advertisement
Whitmer and President Joe Biden tour a Pfizer manufacturing plant in Kalamazoo, Michigan, February 2021, they are wearing masks and talking to two men, one in a suit and another in a high vis vest.

Source: The White House/Flickr

Whitmer explained that the state’s safety is the primary focus of the budget, which includes new laws to reduce gun violence and crack down on domestic abusers. “We want to make sure that every Michigander, no matter where you live, is safe as you go to work, drop your kids off at school, run errands. This budget gets it done,” she said.

Michigan Employment and Economy

The spending plan isn’t just about public safety – it’s likewise about employment and Michigan’s economy. There’s $45.5 million for labor force development, $500 million for the Strategic Outreach Attraction Reserve fund to draw in new businesses, and $60 million for an Innovation Fund to help new businesses. 

The Renaissance Center in Downtown Detroit with the headquarters of General Motors visible, the tall buildings are in front of a bay.

Source: Ritcheypro/Wikimedia Commons

In addition, there is funding to assist individuals in converting to jobs in clean energy and electric vehicles.

Advertisement

Fixing the “Damn Roads”

Maybe most controversial is Whitmer’s greenlighting of a significant $700 million for the last stage of her Remaking Michigan Plan, which will be centered around highways and bridges.

Gretchen Whitmer at the White House for a roundtable discussion on the bipartisan Innovation Act, March 2022, she is flanked by a man and a woman who are in formal wear, there is an American flag in the background.

Source: The White House/Flickr

Michigan residents may recall Whitmer’s campaign for governor in 2018 and her pledge to “fix the damn roads.” Six years later, the progress has been slow at best.

Advertisement

Rebuilding Michigan Debt

Long-term debt from the Rebuilding Michigan program is already looming over Michigan, and with construction and material costs increasing alongside inflation, experts are concerned that this cash infusion to the program won’t extend far enough.

Whitmer and Vice President Kamala Harris at a roundtable discussion in Grand Rapids, Michigan, on the topic of reproductive rights for women, February 2024, there are other women in front of name placards at the table and a sign behind them saying Trust Women

Source: The White House/Flickr

Federal Funds could potentially move development along, and the financial plan contains $4.2 billion for road and bridge projects, which incorporates nearly 2 billion dollars from the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law.

Advertisement

Health and Energy

On the health front, new behavioral health clinics will receive $161.5 million, and the Healthy Moms, Healthy Babies program will receive $18.1 million to close racial health gaps for mothers and babies.

Whitmer discusses Operation Safe Communities a program to remove illegal guns from neighborhoods, May 2023, there is a woman in a suit behind her and police officers in the background

Source: City of Detroit/Flick

Another controversial piece of the spending plan was a $150 million venture to reopen the Palisades Nuclear Facility. 

Advertisement

Environmental Opposition

Whitmer is advocating for the reopening of the Palisades plant, following in the footsteps of California Governor Gavin Newsom, who paid for the Diablo Canyon nuclear plant to remain operational.

Newsom at his second gubernatorial swearing-in ceremony, at the Plaza de California, 2023, he is mid speech as he stands at a podium with mics and sigils for California behind him.

Source: Franco Folini/Flickr

While Whitmer says it will save 600 jobs and make sufficient energy to supply thousands of homes, environmental groups are opposed to the idea. 

Advertisement

Conservative Criticism

Environmental groups say they would prefer Whitmer focus on drinking and wastewater issues, public transport, and household energy efficiency overhauls instead.

Whitmer speaking on federal infrastructure investment for Michigan in Bay City, November 2022, there are people cheering in the crowd behind her with a sign for Building a Better America.

Source: The White House/Flickr

Conservatives likewise aren’t enthused by Whitmer’s new spending plan. They accused Democrats of focusing on “wasteful pet projects for politically favored communities.” The budget, according to some Republicans, does not do enough to fix roads or make schools safer. 

Advertisement

Overlooking Issues

Others accuse Whitmer of overlooking major issues in Northern Michigan that need serious money to tackle.

Whitmer signs voter rights protection bill, November 2023, she is sitting at a table as people stand over her taking pictures and looking down at her.

Source: City of Detroit/Flickr

Despite the fact that numerous neighborhood projects were subsidized, Whitmer rejected almost $9.2 million in requests, including $2.5 million for a religious lodging award and $3 million in rebates to gas stations to boost ethanol sales.

In support of her choices, Whitmer stated, “When we don’t negotiate things, I don’t think anyone should be surprised that they’re taken out of the budget”

Advertisement