Liberal Supreme Court Member Will Not Run Again, Giving Conservatives Room to Retake Control of This Swing State

By: Georgia | Published: Apr 12, 2024

Justice Ann Walsh Bradley of the Wisconsin Supreme Court announced she will not seek reelection for a fourth ten-year term. 

This decision opens up a significant contest for her seat in this crucial battleground state. Her retirement potentially enhances the likelihood of conservatives regaining control, given the current 4-3 liberal majority of which she is a part.

Reflecting on Her Decision

In a statement released Thursday, Justice Bradley shared her thoughts.

Advertisement
Justice Ann Walsh Bradley smiling for the camera, wearing glasses with red detailing and earrings

Source: Wikimedia Commons

She said, “My decision has not come lightly. It is made after careful consideration and reflection. I know I can do the job and do it well. I know I can win reelection, should I run. But, it’s just time to pass the torch, bringing fresh perspectives to the court.”

Advertisement

Looking Ahead to New Chapters

Justice Bradley expressed anticipation for the future.

Advertisement
Justice Ann Walsh Bradley, smiling in a blue jacket, posing next to a man in a pink shirt

Source: Wikimedia Commons

 “Upon completion of my third term, I look forward to embarking upon a new chapter in my life, which will include public service that is guided by the same principles of justice, fairness, and dedication that have defined my tenure on the court,” she said.

Her Enduring Commitment

She also remarked on her commitment during her tenure: “It has been an honor of a lifetime to serve the people of this state and to know that when I am sitting down at the bench, I am standing up for them.”

Advertisement
The interior of the Wisconsin Supreme Courtroom featuring a large historical painting above the bench, marble walls, and wooden justices' chairs

Source: Wikimedia Commons

Her service on the court will conclude on July 31, 2025.

Election's Impact on Court Dynamics

Fox 6 reports that former Justice Janine Geske highlighted the importance of the upcoming election, noting that the election is critical as it will decide who controls the Wisconsin Supreme Court.

Advertisement
Official portrait of Justice Janine Gekse, featuring her smiling with short blonde hair and a black judicial robe

Source: JanineGeske/X

This control is pivotal as the court’s decisions influence various social and legal issues, including abortion and elections.

Geske on the Importance of Judicial Elections

Geske emphasized the importance of judicial turnover: “That’s what happens to a dynamic court, that’s why we elect judges and change every – here it’s every 10 years. But we keep the court changing so people can see who their judges are.”

Wide-angle view of the Wisconsin Supreme Courtroom, with a large painting above the bench, dark wood furnishings, and marble columns

Source: Wikimedia Commons

She noted this keeps the judiciary responsive and reflective of the electorate’s values.

Advertisement

The Stakes of the Election

“This is a critical, critical vote,” Geske stated.

A busy scene inside the Wisconsin State Capitol, with people gathered across multiple levels, some holding signs, indicating a public event or protest

Source: Wikimedia Commons

She pointed out that the next justice will carry considerable influence on the divided court, dealing with major social and legal issues that will shape the state’s judicial landscape.

Advertisement

Liberal Majority's Recent Decisions

Since gaining a majority, the liberal justices have overturned Republican-drawn maps of the state’s legislative districts, among other key decisions, AP News reports.

The dome of the Wisconsin State Capitol against a partly cloudy sky, showcasing the intricate architecture and statues adorning its exterior

Source: Warren LeMay/Wikimedia Commons

This reflects the substantial impact of the current liberal majority which took control following Janet Protasiewicz’s victory in 2023.

Advertisement

The Focus on Abortion

The court is currently handling two challenges to a 174-year-old state law interpreted by conservatives as banning abortion.

A woman in a blue jacket and glasses holds a pink sign reading "BANS OFF OUR BODIES" at a protest, with another protester in the background holding a similar sign

Source: RebeccaForWI/X

The outcomes of these cases could significantly affect the legal status of abortion in Wisconsin, demonstrating the extremely high stakes of maintaining or changing the court’s composition.

Advertisement

Praise for Justice Bradley's Service

Democratic Party of Wisconsin Chair Ben Wikler lauded Justice Bradley’s service.

A man in a plaid shirt takes a selfie with a crowd of people wearing "UNIONS FOR ALL" shirts in the background, symbolizing a union support event

Source: benwikler/X

He said, “Justice Ann Walsh Bradley stands as a giant on the Wisconsin Supreme Court, having embodied for nearly 30 years the best of Wisconsin—with a deep commitment to fairness and a profound respect for the law and our Constitutional rights.”

Advertisement

Conservative Response to Bradley’s Retirement

WisGOP Chairman Brian Schimming reacted to the announcement, indicating a heated campaign ahead.

A man in a suit and red tie appears concerned during an interview on the television show 'UPFRONT', with the show's logo displayed in the background

Source: BrianSchimming/X

“Wisconsin Democrats are undoubtedly calling their out-of-state donors and pre-booking the flights from Hollywood to try and purchase another Supreme Court seat. Voters in Wisconsin are tired of far-left activists on the court, and will elect a common-sense, conservative justice in April,” he said.

Advertisement

Looking Forward to the Election

With the race set for April next year, candidates are preparing for a vigorous campaign. This election is pivotal, as conservatives aim to reclaim control.

The Wisconsin State Capitol building on a bright day, framed by lush green trees and vibrant flower beds in the foreground

Source: Wikimedia Commons

The outcome will not only affect the court’s balance but also has broader implications for the judicial handling of critical issues in Wisconsin.

Advertisement