Federal Appeals Court Upholds School’s Ban on Student’s ‘Only Two Genders’ Shirt

By: Georgia | Published: Jun 12, 2024

The First Circuit Court of Appeals recently made headlines by backing a Massachusetts middle school’s decision to ban a controversial T-shirt. 

Last year, the school asked a student to change his shirt that boldly stated, “There are only two genders.” 

Student Sent Home for Shirt Slogan

The drama unfolded when eighth-grader Liam Morrison defied Nichols Middle School’s request and was sent home. 

Advertisement
A young boy wearing a T-shirt with "There are only two genders" stands in front of a group of smiling men in suits outside a brick building

Source: ADFLegal/X

His refusal sparked a legal battle over the boundaries of free speech within school walls, raising questions about student rights and school policies.

Advertisement

Round Two: T-Shirt Battle Escalated

Undeterred, Liam wore the controversial T-shirt again, this time with the words “only two” covered up by a strip of tape labeled “censored.” 

Advertisement
View from behind a student looking towards a teacher standing in front of a classroom, with other students seated at desks

Source: Taylor Flowe/Unsplash

The school’s repeated demands to remove the shirt intensified the standoff.

Liam's Side of the Story

In an interview with Fox News Digital, Liam asserted his T-shirt targeted no one specifically but expressed a personal belief. 

Advertisement
A circular sign split in half, with one side depicting a male figure and the other a female figure

Source: Tim Mossholder/Unsplash

“I’m just voicing my opinion about a statement that I believe to be true,” he said, addressing concerns about the intent of his message.

Legal Eagles Entered the Fray

The Alliance Defending Freedom jumped into the fray, framing the situation as a fundamental free speech issue.

Advertisement
A judge's wooden gavel resting on a brightly colored rainbow flag, symbolizing LGBTQ+ rights, on a gray textured surface

Source: Wikimedia Commons

“This case wasn’t about T-shirts; it was about a public school telling a middle-schooler that he wasn’t allowed to express a view that differed from their own,” argued David Cortman, senior counsel for the group.

School's Take on the T-Shirt Drama

The school defended its decision.

A person holding a small whiteboard with the message "HELLO my pronouns are" followed by colorful text

Source: Alexander Grey/Unsplash

They cited concerns that the T-shirt might disrupt the learning environment and affect the well-being of transgender and gender non-conforming students.

Advertisement

Judicial Perspective on School Authority

Chief U.S. Circuit Judge David Barron weighed in, highlighting the dilemma: Should school administrators or courts decide what’s appropriate in schools? 

An interior view of a courtroom featuring wooden paneling, two flags (one American, one with stars and a red and blue design), a judge's bench with a state seal, and a blank whiteboard on the side

Source: Wikimedia Commons

His comments illustrate the complexities of balancing school authority and student rights.

Advertisement

Advocacy Group Outraged by Ruling

Newsweek reports that the Alliance Defending Freedom didn’t mince words on social media.

A granite stone inscribed with the text of the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution

Source: Wikimedia Commons

They declared the court’s decision “a clear violation of Liam’s free speech right” and hinted at further legal action.

Advertisement

Legal Counsel Vowed to Fight On

Liam’s attorney, Sam Whiting, criticized the court’s decision in the Boston Herald.

Rear view of a diverse group of attendees seated in chairs at a presentation or lecture, focusing on a speaker in the front of the room

Source: Sam Balye/Unsplash

He argued that the potential for psychological distress among students did not justify censorship, especially when no disruption was evident.

Advertisement

School Advocated for Inclusivity

Deborah Ecker, lawyer for the Middleborough School Committee, emphasized the school’s duty to protect LGBTQ students from messages that could feel alienating or harmful.

Multiple rainbow pride flags fluttering in the breeze, symbolizing LGBTQ+ pride and diversity

Source: daniel james/Unsplash

She framed the T-shirt message as potentially damaging.

Advertisement

Public Opinion Split on School Policy

The controversy sparked a fiery debate both locally and online, with the community split. 

A school bus with the words "USE YOUR VOICE" spray-painted in blue on its back window, alongside other small messages

Source: Stephen Harlan/Unsplash

Discussions revolved around the tension between maintaining a respectful school environment and upholding free speech.

Advertisement

Implications for School Policies Nationwide

As the Alliance Defending Freedom contemplates next steps, including a possible appeal, the outcome of this case could influence future decisions on student expression and school policy across the U.S. 

A classroom scene with diverse students attentively listening to a male teacher who is standing in front of a whiteboard

Source: Kenny Eliason/Unsplash

Meanwhile, the debate over where to draw the line continues to evolve.

Advertisement