Elon Musk’s Battle Against California Causes Tesla Sales to Plummet

By: James Dorman | Published: Aug 07, 2024

Elon Musk, the man who has steered Twitter into the more conservative-centric X, has been locked in an ideological battle with the state of California.

He has many gripes with the liberal Golden State and is not shy about voicing them. But his chickens may be coming home to roost as Tesla sales in California have taken a significant hit.

California’s EV Boom

California is leading the way with regards to drivers adopting electric vehicles (EVs). In 2023, California motorists purchased over 400,000 new EVs.

Advertisement
Close-up of an electric vehicle charging port. A black and white plastic tool with a blue cable leading away from it is plugged into a circular port on the car illuminated with a blue light ring.

Source: CHUTTERSNAP/Unsplash

This makes the state an extremely fertile marketplace for EV manufacturers, and in recent years one brand has been synonymous with the electric auto revolution — Tesla. But there may be trouble ahead for Elon Musk’s company.

Advertisement

Plummeting Tesla Sales

Industry data reveals that demand for Tesla vehicles in the state of California appears to be plummeting.

Advertisement
Cars parked seen in an overhead view with the word Tesla.

(Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)

Based on post-sale registrations recorded when a vehicle’s title is processed, demand for new Teslas nose dived 24% to 52,211 vehicles in the second quarter of this year. This is particularly concerning in a state where more than one in five new cars sold are electric.

A Continuing Trend of Decline

This drop in interest in Tesla marks the third consecutive three-month period of decline compared to last year. Tesla may have reached its peak in 2023 when it hit just over 230,000 vehicles.

Advertisement
A digital illustration of the stock market

Source: Freepik

The California New Car Dealers Association (CNCDA) may have put it best when publishing the figures: “Tesla’s allure seems to be wearing off.”

Better Fortunes for Rivian

While Tesla struggles, others are prospering and making the most of this opportunity to get a greater foothold in the EV market.

Advertisement
Back end of a blue car with “Rivian” written in silver lettering.

Source: Markus Winkler/Unsplash

Registrations of competing Rivian EVs rose by an impressive 69% this quarter to just under 4,000 vehicles, positioning Rivian as the fastest-growing major brand in the state of California.

Reasons for Tesla’s Troubles

There are a number of reasons why the makeup of EVs on California’s highways may be changing. Perhaps the market is naturally adjusting to new competition and greater choice for consumers.

Elon Musk talking into a microphone.

Source: Tesla Owners Club Belgium/Wikimedia Commons

Or perhaps Tesla, or rather Elon Musk, might be responsible for its own declining fortunes. Musk may be actively pushing away EV enthusiasts, particularly those in California.

Advertisement

Reactions on Social Media

Musk recently publicly endorsed Donald Trump, investing tens of millions of dollars into Trump’s presidential election campaign.

A sticker depicting the smiling face of Donald Trump with the words “Miss Me Yet?” written above it stuck to a graffiti-covered surface.

Source: Jon Tyson/Unsplash

This is causing some more liberal EV owners to reassess their association with Musk’s brand. A well-known Malibu Tesla owner Miss Jilianne, who frequently posts videos of Full-Self Driving Tesla beta tests to social media, took to X to express her sentiment that it might be time to ditch her Tesla for a Rivian.

Advertisement

Musk’s Identity Crisis

This highlights what might be part of the issue for Tesla — something of a disconnect between Musk’s personality and his identity and how he tries to position his product offerings.

The symbols of the Democrat and Republican parties cut out of red and blue paper against a black background.

Source: Kelly Sikkema/Unsplash

Electric cars are viewed, almost to the level of parody, as a democratic, liberal fancy. Yet it is precisely this customer base that Musk is alienating by doing things like so enthusiastically supporting Trump and positioning X as a strongly conservative platform.

Advertisement

Elon’s California Feud

If Musk seems to be at odds with Democrats in general, then he’s engaged in an all-out feud with the state of California.

An image of Texas’ famous state flag blowing in the wind against a clear blue sky.

Source: Pete Alexopoulos/Unsplash

Most recently, he announced that he will be moving both SpaceX and X Corp from California to Texas, citing California’s new gender identity law as his reason for doing so.

Advertisement

Tesla Still In a Strong Position, For Now

Tesla is still in a highly dominant position in California’s EV market, despite these recent declines and the gains made by Rivian.

Graphic on a grey concrete floor. A green square with a white illustration of a car with a power cord coming out of the back of it.

Source: Michael Marais/Unsplash

Tesla has a 53% market share in the first half of 2024, meaning all other competitors combined — including Rivian with its 3.6% share — still have fewer EVs on the roads than Tesla.

Advertisement

The Importance of California as an EV Battleground

Even with things still looking healthy currently, Tesla should be concerned about losing ground in California. It’s one of the strongest EV markets in the country, with EVs making up almost three times the new car market in the state compared to the national average.

Image of the Golden Gate Bridge in San Francisco extending across clear, blue/green water on a bright sunny day.

Source: Maarten van den Heuvel/Unsplash

California is an EV pioneer in many regards, including trialing new road-tax models for electric vehicles that may be adopted by other states. There is a position to be taken that as goes California, so goes the national EV market.

Advertisement

Tesla’s Changing Fortunes

The EV market is growing and is only going to get bigger. For the longest time, it seemed there were only a few names in the electric vehicle marketplace, and Tesla was the most prominent among them.

Sign for a Tesla dealership with the company logo against a cloudy sky

Source: Shutterstock

Tesla’s brand identity is intrinsically linked to Musk’s. When such a conservative figure is synonymous with something as liberal as the EV revolution, it’s no wonder consumers are beginning to feel a conflict and are losing their interest in Tesla.

Advertisement