Donald Trump’s Remarks About Putin Spark Debate Following Rally

By: David Donovan | Published: Aug 05, 2024

The message that former President Donald Trump delivered to Russian President Vladimir Putin at a campaign rally on Saturday sparked criticism on social media in light of the prisoner swap that took place this week between the United States and Russia.

As part of a prisoner swap with Moscow, President Joe Biden announced on Thursday that his administration had secured the release of three Americans and one resident of the United States, Vladimir Kara-Murza. 

Prisoner Swap

In exchange for Wall Street Journal reporter Evan Gershkovich, former U.S. Marine Paul Whelan, Russian-American journalist Alsu Kurmasheva, and a number of Russian dissidents held in Russian prisons, the United States and some of its allies agreed to exchange eight Russian detainees. 

Advertisement
Kurmasheva, Gershkovich and Whelan together with government officials and staff on their return flight to the U.S. on 1 August 2024

X user POTUS

A few German nationals were likewise delivered as a part of the arrangement.

Advertisement

Russian Reciprocation

According to the Associated Press, Russia reciprocated by welcoming back a number of Russian citizens who had been found guilty of crimes such as espionage, fraud, and involvement in the shooting death of a Georgian commander.

Advertisement
President Biden with the families of the prisoner swap on August 1 2024

X user POTUS

“I will not stop working until every American wrongfully detained or held hostage around the world is reunited with their family,” According to Biden in a statement released on Thursday.

“70 Such Americans”

Biden continued: “My Administration has now brought home over 70 such Americans, many of whom were in captivity since before I took office.”

Advertisement
President Biden in the Oval Office with the families of the prisoner swap

X user POTUS

Trump traveled to the Georgia State University Convocation Center in Atlanta for a campaign rally on Saturday. During the rally, Trump, the GOP’s 2024 official candidate, talked about the detainee trade as he complimented the Russian leader.

Congratulating Putin

Trump stated: “By the way I would like to congratulate Vladimir Putin for having made yet another great deal. Did you see the deal we made?”

Advertisement
Trump speaking at CPAC 2011 with a woman standing off to the side

Flickr user Mark Taylor

Since Trump’s comments, a few users have taken to X, previously Twitter, to reprimand the former president for his message to Putin.

“Horrifying Moment”

“In a horrifying moment, Donald Trump congratulates Vladimir Putin,” wrote the online community supporting Vice President Kamala Harris in the 2024 election on the X account Kamala’s Wins. 

Vladimir Putin holds a video call with U.S. president Joe Biden on 7 December 2021

Kremlin.ru

The post continues: “Trump has long sided with Russia and Putin, but congratulating him at a campaign rally is as anti-American and repulsive as it gets. Retweet so all Americans see this.”

Advertisement

Biden Resignation

Since Biden resigned from the race on July 21 and endorsed his vice president, Trump is now expected to face Harris, the presumptive Democratic presidential nominee. Previously, Trump was expected to compete against Biden in this year’s election.

Putin with U.S. president Donald Trump at the summit meeting in Helsinki, Finland, 16 July 2018

Kremlin.ru

In the meantime, Trump’s rumored connections to Putin were scrutinized while he was president. 

Advertisement

Trump Claims

Trump has previously praised Putin for being “smart” and boasted about his good relations with the Russian leader. 

Putin speaking at the "Russia-Africa" parliamentary conference in Moscow on 20 March 2023.

Duma.gov.ru

He even claimed, without providing any specifics, that if he is reelected, he could end the ongoing war between Russia and Ukraine that Putin started in February 2022 within “24 hours.”

Advertisement

“Traitor”

“I like a president who does not congratulate Vladimir Putin” was written on the X account “Republicans against Trump.”

Ukrainian president Zelenskyy, German chancellor Merkel, French president Macron and Putin met in Paris on 9 December 2019

Kremlin.ru

“Paul Whelan was held hostage for 5 years and he’s congratulating Putin. Trump is a traitor.” was one of the comments that Michigan GOP Watch user wrote about Trump.

Advertisement

Potentially Dangerous Citizens

Joshua Reed Eakle, another user of X, wrote, “Not Americans. Not Biden. Not the Americans being held as political prisoners. Vladimir Putin. What a repugnant, anti-American human being.”

Joshua Reed Eakes posing for a photo with another man

X user JoshEakle

In the past, Trump has criticized Biden’s handling of prisoner swaps, accusing him of trading potentially dangerous Russian citizens for hostages held by U.S. citizens. 

Advertisement

Trump’s Swaps

The former president has suggested that Biden could secure releases without making any concessions, claiming that Biden’s deals are “one-sided.”

Trump with the other G7 leaders at the 45th summit in France, 2019

Flickr user The White House

But Trump also did prisoner swaps while he was president. He gave up three Taliban leaders in November 2019 in exchange for two Americans, Kevin King and Timothy Weeks. 

Advertisement

Administration Numbers

The next year, the U.S. returned an Iranian researcher only days before Iran delivered Marine Michael White from custody, however authorities rejected that this was a detainee trade.

Putin and Trump shaking hands at the G20 Osaka summit, June 2019

Flickr user The White House

58 hostages, according to Trump, were freed while he was president. In the meantime, the online archive of the Trump White House stated that Trump had released 56 hostages “from more than 24 countries.”

The White House claims that Biden has secured the release of over 70 Americans in various hostage releases worldwide.

Advertisement