Did Gavin Newsom Abandon California?

By: Georgia | Published: Mar 04, 2024

In California, a new recall effort is targeting Governor Gavin Newsom, who is accused by the group Rescue California of prioritizing his presidential ambitions over addressing state issues.

This marks another significant challenge to Newsom’s governance, coming less than three years after he successfully defeated a previous recall attempt.

Hundreds of Signatures Submitted to Begin Recall Process

The recall initiative began with the submission of almost 500 signatures by Rescue California, signaling the start of a formal attempt to oust Governor Newsom, ABC7 reports.

Advertisement
Three individuals are standing outdoors holding signs that read "RESCUE CALIFORNIA RECALL GAVIN NEWSOM,"

Source: Rescue California/Facebook

Anne Hyde Dunsmore, campaign director for Rescue California, emphasized the urgency and determination of their campaign, saying, “California needs a full-time governor who is fully focused on the serious problems the state and its citizens are facing. This may be our last opportunity to rescue and restore our state, while we highlight for the rest of the country the destruction Newsom has left in his wake.”

Advertisement

Rescue California Criticizes Newsom's Leadership

Rescue California accuses Governor Newsom of neglecting critical state issues, including homelessness and education, to further his own political ambitions.

Advertisement
A large banner is displayed in front of a building with classical architecture, featuring the silhouette of California in gold against a white background. The banner reads "RESCUE CALIFORNIA... RECALL GAVIN NEWSOM"

Source: Rescue California/Facebook

The group’s website states that Newsom “has abandoned the state to advance his Presidential ambitions,” showcasing their central argument for the recall. They believe Newsom’s focus is not on the Californian residents who require attentive governance.

Financial Management and State Deficit Under Scrutiny

The group also points to California’s significant budget deficit, arguing that Newsom’s financial leadership is questionable. “We now have a $73 billion deficit. He is not qualified. Right now, he is not doing his job and he certainly shouldn’t be applying for another one,” Dunsmore stated.

Advertisement
A crowd of protesters, some holding American flags and others with signs, gathered at a rally. Several signs are visible with messages including "RECALL Gavin Newsom," "Our Governor is An Idiot! Demand Recall!!", and "NO NEW NORMAL".

Source: Rescue California/Facebook

The state faces a projected $73 billion budget shortfall, which critics attribute to Newsom’s governance. This financial crisis is a key point in the recall campaign, spotlighting concerns over fiscal responsibility.

Newsom Responds to Recall Efforts on Social Media

On the social media platform X, formerly known as Twitter, Governor Newsom addressed the recall campaign, describing it as a distraction by “Trump Republicans” from crucial issues such as democracy and reproductive freedom.

Advertisement
A screenshot of a social media post by Gavin Newsom. The post reads: "Trump Republicans are launching another wasteful recall campaign to distract us from the existential fight for democracy and reproductive freedom. We will defeat them."

Source: GavinNewsom/X

He expressed confidence in overcoming this political challenge, reinforcing his commitment to the state’s values.

Newsom's Team Responds to Recall with Determination

Nathan Click, representing Governor Newsom, emphasized the administration’s serious approach to the recall challenge.

President Joe Biden is seated at the Resolute Desk in the Oval Office, signing a document, with Vice President Kamala Harris standing behind him to the left. Both are dressed formally, President Biden in a dark suit with a red and blue striped tie, and Vice President Harris in a blue blazer. An American flag and the Presidential flag are positioned behind them

Source: POTUS/X

He said, “We are taking it seriously. These Trump Republicans are targeting Gov. Newsom because he is out there defending democracy and fighting for the reelection of Joe Biden and Kamala Harris. He’s not going to be distracted from that fight. Democracy’s on the ballot, and he’s going to keep fighting.”

Advertisement

Democratic Leaders Support Newsom

ABC7 notes that prominent California Democrats have quickly come to Newsom’s defense, criticizing the recall attempt as unfounded.

A close-up image of Rob Bonta with neatly combed hair speaking outdoors. He is wearing a suit and looks directly at the camera with a serious expression

Source: Wikimedia Commons

Their support reflects the broader political battle lines being drawn in the state, with significant figures rallying around the governor to counter the recall narrative.

Advertisement

Political Analysts Weigh In on Recall's Impact

Political experts, such as Menlo College’s Professor Melissa Michelson, provide context for the recall, suggesting that while Newsom has previously navigated similar challenges successfully, the persistent efforts could influence perceptions of his leadership.

Governor Gavin Newsom, in a dark suit, is bending over a table to sign a document, with a young child standing next to him looking on. They are surrounded by a diverse group of people wearing yellow shirts that read "CHILD CARE PROVIDERS AND PARENTS UNITE."

Source: Wikimedia Commons

The financial and policy criticisms, she notes, might affect not just his governorship but also his potential national political ambitions.

Advertisement

The Signature Threshold for Recall Campaign

The process to initiate a recall against Governor Newsom demands rigorous criteria be met, specifically in the collection of signatures.

Governor Gavin Newsom is captured from the side as he speaks at a podium. He is dressed in a dark suit and is gesturing with his right hand, appearing to address an audience at a formal event

Source: Wikimedia Commons

Organizers must gather signatures equating to 12 percent of the voter turnout in the last election for governor, which translates to approximately 1.38 million signatures. However, to buffer against the possibility of invalid signatures, the campaign estimates a safer target would be around 1.6 million signatures.

Advertisement

Policy Decisions at the Heart of Recall Efforts

The policy decisions made by Newsom’s administration, particularly concerning health benefits for undocumented immigrants and the state’s approach to criminal justice and homelessness, are central to the recall’s critique.

A photograph showing a homeless encampment with tents and assorted belongings covered in tarps on a sidewalk. The encampment is situated in an urban setting with trees, a street, and a large, white building in the background

Source: Wikimedia Commons

Opponents argue these policies have had detrimental effects on the state’s safety and economy.

Advertisement

Governor's National Political Activities Scrutinized

As Governor Newsom engages in national political activities, supporting President Biden and debating with figures like Governor Ron DeSantis, critics question his focus on California’s pressing issues.

President Joe Biden and Governor Gavin Newsom are in a friendly embrace, greeting each other with smiles. Both are wearing dark suits and are outside, with the President in sunglasses

Source: Wikimedia Commons

The recall campaign uses these activities to argue that Newsom is neglecting his duties as governor.

Advertisement

Reflecting on the 2021 Recall Attempt

The current recall effort follows Newsom’s victory against a previous recall attempt in 2021, where he maintained his position by a substantial margin.

Governor Gavin Newsom stands in a classroom, gesturing with his hand mid-speech. He is wearing a dark suit and tie

Source: GavinNewsom/X

This historical context is significant as it demonstrates the political resilience of Newsom, despite ongoing challenges to his administration.

Advertisement