California Scraps $20 Billion Affordable Housing Initiative

By: Georgia | Published: Aug 19, 2024

The Bay Area Housing Finance Authority (BAHFA) has decided not to place a $20-billion proposal aimed at creating more affordable housing in the Bay Area on the November ballot. 

The region, known for its high real estate costs, will not see voters decide on this significant measure this year, delaying potential solutions to its housing affordability crisis.

Recent Decision Reverses Earlier Plans

BAHFA had announced plans just two months prior to introduce the Affordable Housing Bond to voters in November. 

Advertisement
Photo of an older apartment building with a faded yellow exterior, ornate metal balconies, and visible wear, set against a clear sky

Source: Patrick Ho/Unsplash

However, in a recent shift, they decided against including the borrowing plan in this year’s election, suggesting that 2026 might offer a more favorable timing for its passage.

Advertisement

Funding and Voter Approval Challenges

The proposed $20 billion bond intended to finance the construction and preservation of subsidized housing was to be funded by a surcharge on homeowners’ property taxes. 

Advertisement
Image of a single-story suburban house with white walls and a red door, surrounded by lush landscaping and tall trees under a dramatically orange-tinted stormy sky

Source: Gus Ruballo/Unsplash

The measure faced tough prospects as it required over 67 percent voter approval, but recent polls showed only 55 percent support, indicating insufficient backing.

Official Statement on Withdrawal

BAHFA leaders Alfredo Pedroza and Belia Ramos released a statement explaining the board’s decision.

Advertisement
Photo of a traditional blue house with white trim and a white picket fence, showcasing manicured shrubs and a clear blue sky

Source: Gustavo Zambelli/Unsplash

They said, “The BAHFA Board’s decision to withdraw the affordable housing bond measure from this November’s ballot is not one that was taken lightly,” acknowledging the complex nature of the housing crisis and the need for a collective regional effort.

Strategic Delay Explained

The statement from BAHFA continued, “Recent developments have led the board to conclude that the wise choice is to look ahead to another election season for a regional housing measure.” 

Advertisement
Aerial view of a suburban street lined with palm trees, showing houses with varied architecture and gardens, under clear skies

Source: Matthew LeJune/Unsplash

They are waiting for more certainty and for voters to affirmatively weigh in on Proposition 5.

Foundation for Future Efforts

Pedroza and Ramos emphasized that the groundwork done this year was not in vain.

Image of a two-story Victorian house painted in dark blue with elaborate white and red trimmings

Source: David Vives/Unsplash

They said, “Their work to prepare for a November bond measure, and the relationships built along the way, have laid a strong foundation for future success.”

Advertisement

Sector Reactions to the Decision

Heather Hood of Enterprise Community Partners commented on the withdrawal.

A dense aerial view of variously styled residential buildings in San Francisco, showcasing a mix of pastel and neutral-colored facades

Source: Sam Ellis/Unsplash

She said, “We are recommending that you pull (the measure) from the ballot and I really deeply regret this recommendation,” she said, expressing a sense of deep responsibility and urgency.

Advertisement

Proposition 5 Offers New Hope

In the wake of the decision, attention turns to Proposition 5, a separate measure set for the November ballot that proposes lowering the approval threshold for housing measures from two-thirds to 55 percent. 

A line of modern townhouses with varying facades including elements of brick, stucco, and pastel colors, under a cloudy sky.

Source: Flipboard/Unsplash

This change could significantly affect future housing efforts in the Bay Area.

Advertisement

Importance of Strategic Timing

Federal D. Glover, a Contra Costa County Supervisor and BAHFA board member, highlighted the importance of strategy in voter communication.

Classic Victorian houses in the foreground with the modern San Francisco skyline in the background

Source: Jack Finnigan/Unsplash

“We have to be strategic,” he said, pointing to the necessity of choosing the right time to present such critical measures to the public.

Advertisement

Insights from Local Government

Santa Clara County Supervisor Cindy Chavez reflected on the timing of the housing measure.

A woman smiling while holding a clear glass award at a formal event, with other guests and floral decorations in the background

Source: SupCindyChavez/X

“We know that we need the best shot in communicating with the voters in a way that helps people understand how important this opportunity is to getting housing built in our community, and that the timing was off,” she said.

Advertisement

Potential Impact of the Bond

The BAHFA had projected that, if approved, the bond would facilitate the creation of approximately 72,000 new affordable homes across the Bay Area. 

Panoramic view of San Francisco Bay during dusk, showing residential areas in the foreground and the city skyline with mountains in the distance

Source: Charlie Lederer/Unsplash

This illustrates the significant potential impact of the funding on the regional housing landscape.

Advertisement

Continuing the Fight for Affordable Housing

Despite the postponement, BAHFA’s commitment to enhancing affordable housing remains steadfast. 

Sunset view of a San Francisco neighborhood, showcasing residential buildings with a backdrop of the city's downtown skyline and soft clouds in the sky

Source: Josh Hild/Unsplash

The board is looking forward to resuming its efforts, partnering with local governments and organizations to ultimately achieve their goal of more affordable housing in the Bay Area.

Advertisement