‘Bad Idea’ – Scientists in Cape Cod Have Controversial Plans for Climate Change Experiment

By: David Donovan | Published: Jul 17, 2024

Fishermen and environmentalists are standing up against a proposal from a group of researchers who want to dump over 60,000 gallons of sodium hydroxide, also known as lye, into the sea off Cape Cod.

This is being undertaken in an effort to understand how to slow environmental change.

Field Trial

Researchers from Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution in Falmouth are looking for a government license for their venture.

Advertisement
Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution Village Campus. 569 Woods Hole Road, Woods Hole, Massachusetts.

Wikimedia Commons user Kenneth C. Zirkel

This would begin at some point this summer with a field preliminary program that would scatter about 6,600 gallons 10 miles south of Martha’s Vineyard.

Advertisement

LOC-NESS Project

Woods Hole says there are two focal objectives to its alleged LOC-NESS project, which is short for “Locking away Ocean Carbon in the Northeast Shelf and Slope.”

Advertisement
The Research Vessel Atlantis is operated by the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution

Wikipedia user Nsandel

The first aim is to “understand potential environmental impacts of using ocean alkalinity enhancement to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere.” 

“Supplemental Efforts”

The other goal is to “verify and report the amount of carbon dioxide this method might realistically remove if deployed at scale.”

Advertisement
A group of scientist onboard a vessel in the ocean posing for a picture

Facebook user Madeline Fresonke

“While emission reductions are key to minimizing human impact on Earth’s climate, it has become clear in recent years that drastic emission reductions must be supplemented by efforts to actively remove existing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere,” Woods Hole researchers stated in their application to the Environmental Protection Agency.

Larger Scale

Environmentalists and fishermen are not embracing the proposed effort which would continue into the following summer at a larger scale.

Advertisement
view of Provincetown from Pilgrim Monument looking east, MA, USA

Wikimedia Commons user WesportWiki

This would be scaled up to approximately 60,000 gallons in the waters northeast of Provincetown, in the Gulf of Maine.

Sea Alkalinity Enhancement

Friends of the Earth is one of the many groups that appealed to the EPA against the undertaking during a public remark period that ended on Friday.

Friends of the Earth presentation on fracking in a lecture hall

X user foeireland

They underlined how sea alkalinity enhancement- a process that adds alkaline substances to seawater to alter the pH and improve the sea’s natural carbon sink – is “under moratoria under the United Nations Convention on Biological Diversity due to the risks and uncertainties that these technologies entail to biodiversity and ecosystems.”

Advertisement

“Bad Idea”

“Sodium hydroxide is an incredibly dangerous substance,” Friends of the Earth senior campaigner Benjamin Day informed the Herald. 

Headshot of Benjamin Day of Friends of the Earth

foe.org

“It causes chemical burns if it touches your skin or marine animals. We think dumping tens of thousands gallons of that into the ocean is a bad idea.”

Advertisement

Immediate Dangers

Propositions normally seen for alkalinity enhancement use minerals, similar to limestone, that present a “different set of problems,” Day said. 

Friends of the Earth members holding banners outside of a building

X user friends_earth

Sodium hydroxide presents more immediate dangers, he also stated.

Advertisement

Safety Precautions

Woods Hole researchers say the venture will “operate within a pH range considered safe for aquatic life (and) maintain strict environmental monitoring protocols.”

Ocean science discovery center sign outside of a white building

Facebook user WHOI

Researchers will then, at that point, continually screen the alkalinity fix, “using a suite of instruments, sensors, and sampling equipment.”

Advertisement

Impact on Marine Life

“The results of these monitoring efforts will provide some of the first in-water measurements of the safety of OAE,” researchers have said. 

Copepods of different species. For the photo, the darkfield method was combined with polarization.

Wikimedia Commons user Andrei Savitsky

“Including its impacts on water chemistry, the marine food web, and larger organisms such as copepods.”

Advertisement

Understanding Required

Alison Brizius, head of the Massachusetts Office of Coastal Zone Management, says she accepts the undertaking is required to figure out the viability of marine carbon dioxide expulsion.

Alison Brizius posing fo a headshot

boston.gov

“This study has the potential to inform future work as mCDR research continues and possible commercial-scale applications are developed,” she stated in a letter to the EPA on Friday.

Advertisement

Fishermen Response

Robert Scammon, a commercial groundfish captain who has fished the Gulf of Maine and George’s Bank for 37 years, said the designated region for testing has created 30 to 40% of his catch in that time.

Fisherman in yellow overalls next to a fishing vessel docked at a pier

Unsplash user Paul Einerhand

Jerry Leeman, CEO and founder behind the New England Fishermen’s Stewardship Association, added he thinks the “project is being done in haste, and without proper oversight.”

“Major impacts to the commercial and recreational fisheries are likely, which would cause severe economic turmoil (and loss of commercial and recreation opportunities) to the neighboring states’ fisheries, in addition to the immediate test site.”

Advertisement