17,000 Californians to be Stripped of Fire Insurance

By: Georgia | Published: Aug 29, 2024

Liberty Mutual is saying goodbye to fire insurance for 17,000 California policyholders, blaming old technology for the cutoff. 

The coverage will cease by November, as highlighted by The San Francisco Chronicle. This move is part of a larger trend where insurers are withdrawing from the state, but Liberty Mutual insists it’s a tech issue, not financial pressure driving the change.

What is Dwelling Fire Insurance?

Unlike your average homeowner’s insurance, dwelling fire insurance focuses solely on the physical structure of a home in the event of fire, skipping the contents inside. 

Advertisement
Smoke and flames erupt from a house behind a chain-link fence, surrounded by lush green trees under a clear sky

Source: Wikimedia Commons

It’s particularly popular among those who own secondary homes or rental properties—think landlords or vacation home investors.

Advertisement

Out with the Old Tech

Liberty Mutual is ditching the old tech that supports these policies, stating, “it is not feasible to create a new system to support this product in California.” 

Advertisement
Firefighters extend a ladder to a multi-story residential building with smoke around it, in a densely populated urban area

Source: Wikimedia Commons

This change affects policyholders beyond California’s borders, impacting others wherever the same outdated systems are in use.

The Personal Side of Policy Cancellation

For long-time customer Beth Brown from San Francisco, losing her fire insurance felt like a personal betrayal.

Advertisement
A red fire engine, parked on a city street at dusk, with emergency lights on and a firefighter standing beside it

Source: Wikimedia Commons

She shared with The San Francisco Chronicle, “the nonrenewal was ‘sort of like a boyfriend who breaks up with you and can’t really tell you why.'” Despite regularly renovating her home, she’s now left without coverage.

Still a Major Player

Despite cutting some of its services, Liberty Mutual hasn’t left the California market entirely. 

Advertisement
The facade of the Liberty Mutual Insurance Company building, a tall gray structure with the company's name in gold lettering

Source: Wikimedia Commons

They still hold nearly 10% of the state’s fire insurance market share. But as the risk of climate disasters grows, they’re reconsidering their involvement, much like other companies.

Insurance Crisis Hits Home

The insurance landscape in California is shifting dramatically, with more than half of the state’s residents experiencing hikes in premiums or outright loss of coverage over the past year. 

A quaint single-story house with a well-maintained garden under a dramatic orange sky, possibly indicative of nearby wildfire smoke

Source: Gus Ruballo/Unsplash

A report by Redfin puts the spotlight on these troubling trends.

Advertisement

The Park Fire: A Catastrophic Blaze

This year’s Park Fire, triggered by an unusual incident involving a burning car, has devoured over 429,000 acres, making it the fourth-largest wildfire in California’s recorded history. 

Tall pine trees stand against a fiery background as flames consume a fallen tree on the forest floor, under a glowing orange night sky

Source: TMcGillWeather/X

The damage to structures is immense, pushing the state’s insurance resources to the limit.

Advertisement

Wildfires on the Rise

Fire officials report that over 3,500 wildfires have ravaged 219,247 acres across California just by mid-year.

A distant wildfire lights up the hillside at dusk, visible from a road where the red streaks of passing cars' tail lights blur in the foreground

Source: Wikimedia Commons

This uptick in both the number and severity of fires is complicating the landscape for insurers, who are forced to reassess their risk models.

Advertisement

Premiums Skyrocket

Insurance premiums are soaring, as evidenced by Jeff Waack’s experience in West Hollywood. 

Low angle view of a tall red brick building under a clear blue sky, featuring a fire escape and several rows of white windows

Source: John Salzarulo/Unsplash

His building’s annual insurance cost has rocketed from $23,000 to an astounding $116,000. Despite attempts to secure a reasonable offer, no insurance company has been willing to take on the policy, he told DailyMail.com.

Advertisement

Urban Insurance Woes

Even urban areas like West Hollywood are feeling the insurance pinch. 

A bright, white-painted multi-story residential building with green shutters and lush greenery around it under a blue sky

Source: Wikimedia Commons

Despite a lower risk of natural disasters, residents are finding it increasingly difficult to secure affordable insurance, highlighting a broader state-wide issue.

Advertisement

Desperate for Coverage

In a last-ditch effort to find insurance, Waack’s condo association turned to a non-California admitted insurer, a company that operates without state backing. 

Sunlight casts shadows on an old, beige apartment building with ornate metal balconies and architectural details

Source: Patrick Ho/Unsplash

This step illustrates the desperation many Californians face in securing any form of insurance protection.

Advertisement

A State of Insurance Flux

Liberty Mutual’s exit from offering certain types of fire insurance in California reflects a wider industry pullback from regions considered high risk.

A firefighter stands silhouetted against the intense flames consuming a house and car at night, with smoke and embers filling the air

Source: Wikimedia Commons

This retreat is reshaping the insurance availability and cost for many Californians, leaving a future filled with uncertainty as they navigate the evolving challenges posed by climate change and outdated technology.

Advertisement